Dividend & Growth Allocation (DGA)
Developed by Paul Choi · Multi-Momentum · Med-High Risk
Dividend & Growth Allocation was developed by Paul Choi and published as SSRN paper #4633601. DGA introduces a multi-layer tactical framework that rotates between US growth equities and dividend equities based on a combination of momentum signals and macro regime indicators. The strategy addresses a challenge specific to equity income investors: the historical tendency for dividend-focused portfolios to underperform growth-oriented allocations during technology-driven bull markets, and for growth portfolios to suffer deeper drawdowns during economic contractions when dividend-paying companies' more stable earnings provide relative protection.
The core innovation is the layered signal architecture that combines a canary-based crash detection mechanism with a multi-period momentum composite for equity style selection. The canary layer uses TIP (Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities) momentum as a macro regime indicator — when TIP momentum is negative, signaling deteriorating real yield conditions, the portfolio shifts entirely to defensive assets. When the macro environment is favorable, the strategy compares US tech/growth (QQQ) against US dividend equities (SCHD) using a multi-factor momentum composite and holds the winner.
The defensive side provides three alternatives — short-term Treasuries (BIL), long-term Treasuries (TLT), and commodities (PDBC) — selected dynamically based on their relative momentum. This expanded defensive menu allows the strategy to protect effectively across different types of market stress: TLT for deflationary recessions, BIL for inflationary tightening, and PDBC for stagflationary environments. The adaptive defense overcomes the limitation of strategies that rely on a single bond instrument for protection.
DGA's rotation between growth and dividend equities captures the style rotation cycle that has become increasingly prominent as the US equity market has diverged into distinct growth and value regimes. During technology-driven expansions, QQQ substantially outperforms dividend-focused indices. During value rotations, economic recoveries, and rising-rate environments, dividend equities tend to outperform growth. The momentum-based selection systematically positions on the right side of this rotation without requiring macro forecasts about which style will lead.
How It Works
TIP Canary Gate
Each month, the strategy first evaluates TIP's multi-period momentum composite. If TIP momentum is negative — indicating that real yields are rising or inflation expectations are shifting in a way that creates headwinds for risk assets — the entire portfolio shifts to defensive positioning. The TIP canary captures macro conditions that affect both growth and dividend equities, providing a broad protective gate that operates independently of the equity style selection.
The single-canary design is deliberately simple. TIP's sensitivity to both real rate changes and inflation expectations makes it a comprehensive macro indicator that detects diverse types of market stress through a single instrument. Rising real rates pressure equity valuations (hurting growth stocks disproportionately), while shifting inflation expectations can disrupt dividend stocks' relative value proposition — making TIP deterioration relevant to both equity styles.
Growth vs. Dividend Rotation
When the TIP canary is positive, the strategy compares US tech/growth equities (QQQ) against US dividend equities (SCHD) using a multi-factor momentum composite. The style showing stronger recent momentum receives the entire equity allocation, concentrating the portfolio in whichever equity approach is currently being rewarded by the market.
This binary rotation between growth and dividend equities captures the most significant style rotation cycle in US equity markets. During the 2010-2020 decade, QQQ dramatically outperformed SCHD as low interest rates and technology disruption drove growth stocks to historic premiums. During 2022 and portions of the value rotations, SCHD outperformed as rising rates compressed growth valuations while dividend stocks' cash flows provided relative stability. The momentum signal systematically identifies which regime is currently in effect.
Adaptive Defensive Selection
During defensive periods (TIP canary negative), the portfolio selects among three instruments based on their relative momentum: short-term Treasuries (BIL) for capital preservation during rate-hiking environments, long-term Treasuries (TLT) for duration gains during deflationary recessions, and commodities (PDBC) for inflation-hedging during stagflationary conditions. The adaptive selection means the defense matches the type of market stress occurring.
This three-instrument defensive menu overcomes a critical weakness of single-instrument defense strategies. During 2022, strategies relying on TLT for protection suffered alongside equities as rates rose aggressively. A strategy that could rotate to BIL or PDBC during such environments preserves capital more effectively. The momentum-based defensive selection identifies which safe haven is performing best in real time, adapting to the prevailing stress type without requiring the investor to diagnose the nature of the market decline.
Explore Dividend & Growth Allocation (DGA)
See the full backtest across 18 years of market data, or run your own what-if scenarios by adjusting all research parameters.